Where’s the Christian Social Gospel when we need it?

WWJD?   What would Jesus do?

My first exposure to that question came back in the mid 1990’s when I was teaching an adult Sunday School class using Charles Shelton’s 1890’s classic, “In His Steps.” Back then I had some concern that coming out of the 1980’s we American’s were now in the throws of what political scientists call a new “corporatist oligarchy” replacing our former social democracy.   Likewise, in the throws of what historians call a new “gilded age”   —  much like the one Shelton lived through when writing his book 100 years earlier. For those unfamiliar with such terms, America’s original “gilded age” featured the emergence of industrial corporations that brought severe disparities in class, wealth, and living standards.

My main idea in offering up that centennial reading and discussion of the Shelton book back then was to seek a mini-renewal, at least at our local level in United Methodism, of the American “social Gospel” that had emerged in response to our 19th century “gilded age” of class disparity. The 1890’s gave witness to a kind of tall-steeple churchism, if I may coin that term, within American Christianity, losing touch with the basic teachings and behavioral examples of Jesus himself. Hence, Shelton’s fictional book that posed the question, “what would Jesus do?” Or WWJD as his preferred acronym.

The 1990’s, it now turns out, came and went without much of a social Gospel influence. Some, such as my evangelism mentor, Steve Sjogren, worked out of a “servant evangelism” model at a kind of micro level. Yet, nothing on a macro or systemic level really came to occur, and perhaps for that reason our gilded age of corporate rule in government and society has spawned a time in our history of unparalleled inequality between the haves and have nots. Three decades later, our lack of a coherent social Gospel in American Christianity is mostly conspicuous by its own absence.

Today’s best example of such a gilded age on steroids may well be the new American Health Care Act (AHCA) now winding its way through our U.S. Congress. Its unwritten and unspoken goal is to shift the financial risk of illness from the community to the individual. Individuals with good health and great wealth will be taken care of. Those with poor health or great poverty (the two strongly intertwined in virtually every social research study ever conducted) are left, basically, to die or file bankruptcy. Or both. It’s the new gilded age absent any coherent social Gospel response at the larger, national level.  It’s runaway hedonic greed and narcissism without any pushback from the church.

So what would Jesus do about healthcare in the United States today? WWJD?

Most of my fellow pastors and priests would seek to bear influence at the local or more micro level of community. Hire a parish nurse perhaps. Offer some CPR training or conduct weekly free blood pressure screenings. Pay for an occasional medical prescription. Visit the sick in hospitals and nursing homes. Or, if feasible, these local churches might throw open their doors for a free clinic in their own neighborhood.

I won’t disparage such reactions to the healthcare needs of today’s and tomorrow’s have nots in America.

But I have to wonder.

Would Jesus be so small as to do something no bigger than this? Nothing beyond the micro level of care?   Is Jesus really that limited in caring-capacity?

Or would Jesus act on a larger, more systemic level to influence and impact healthcare for those marginalized by poor health and intermingling poverty?

Given the thrust of Jesus’s original teachings, centered around the Kingdom of God as a systemic solution to human social and spiritual problems, my faith is 100% invested in Jesus doing something at a systems-level where healthcare is concerned for the masses of our marginalized Americans today. He would not neglect the local village, but as before he would merely use such villages and villagers as a microcosm for the Kingdom work necessary for the greater common good.

I wonder if Jesus would not today support universal healthcare aimed at comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable. I wonder if he would not inspire a new social Gospel movement in our nation today.   Just as Jesus did in his own nation two millennia ago. A new social Gospel that included healthcare for everyone, not just the privileged classes.

I wonder if, given the relative success of America’s own public Medicare insurance for the elderly and permanently disabled, Jesus would not affirm a Medicare-For-All plan covering our residents of all ages, classes, villages and states. I wonder if he would not attach some personal risk and responsibility for everyone in that system by imposing a sliding fee scale premium plus co-pay plus deductible, tied to whatever income source one has. Perhaps down to $5.00 per month per person in the three areas of premium, co-pay, and deductible. Given Medicare’s comparatively low administrative costs as a non-profit insurance provider, I wonder if he would not advocate for such a system of universal care, then using the for profit sector only in the area of Medicare supplemental insurance for those wanting more and longer covered benefits. And I wonder if Jesus would not advocate for a non-profit supplemental insurance such as state Medicaid with means tested premiums for those needing more and longer covered benefits. Perhaps also lowered to $5 per month per person for the poorest in our land, no co-pay or deductible charges for service.

The reason my mind wonders if Jesus would not act in this larger, systemic direction is that, by all indications from our biblical Gospel records, Jesus believed healthcare was a right and not a privilege. This was so as regarded mental as well as bodily afflictions. And certainly without regard to wealth or material status. If after reading through the Gospels you can cite indications about Jesus to the contrary, feel free to leave a comment below. I’m willing to wonder in a new or different direction with you given strong biblical evidence.

The gilded age of modern medicine is once again upon us. I will likely never stop imagining that Jesus would offer up a social Gospel response and responsibility for all of his followers. In fact, my own mind has settled into a long held belief that religion itself is our human gift to God while science, especially medical science, is God’s gift to humanity. God’s gift is far more useful for us than our gift is for God, yet if any of us should hoard God’s gift or deny or refuse it whatsoever, we may well find ourselves on the afflicted, not comforted, end of God’s timeless equation made known through Jesus.

WWJD today in America?




One thought on “Where’s the Christian Social Gospel when we need it?

  1. Michael Mahoney says:

    We do live in a new guilded age. My family and I are currently on vacation in a rented vacation home for a week at Croatan Beach just outside of Virgina Beach. In my morning walk I observe new multi million dollar vacation homes being built here. When we drive home to Columbus on Saturday we will go through one of the most poverty stricken areas of our country in West Virginia.

    There is a lack of compassion in this country.
    Amos and Hosea would recognize our condition for what it is.
    Single payer healthcare with a sliding scare would make us a more just society.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s